This question comes up constantly, usually from sellers who are trying to figure out the “right order” to set up their business — form an LLC first, then get insurance? Or the other way around? The short answer removes a common blocker: you don’t need to wait.
This article is for general information only and isn’t a substitute for advice from a licensed insurance agent, attorney, or accountant. Business structure decisions have legal and tax implications specific to your situation — consider professional advice before forming or not forming an LLC.
The short answer
No. You can buy business insurance — general liability, product liability, or both — as a sole proprietor, without ever forming an LLC. Insurance providers that serve Etsy and handmade sellers routinely issue policies to sole proprietors, and there’s no requirement to have a formal business entity in place first.
Why these two things get confused
LLCs and insurance both relate to protecting yourself from business risk, which is probably why people assume one is a prerequisite for the other. But they protect you in different ways:
- An LLC (Limited Liability Company) is a legal business structure that, in general, separates your personal assets from your business’s legal and financial liabilities — meaning if your business is sued, your personal savings, home, and other assets are typically shielded, provided you maintain proper separation between personal and business finances.
- Insurance is a financial product that pays out (up to policy limits) if a covered claim occurs — regardless of whether you operate as a sole proprietor or an LLC.
They solve overlapping but distinct problems. An LLC without insurance still leaves you facing claims — the business entity might be sued, but there’s no funding source to actually pay a claim beyond what the business itself has. Insurance without an LLC still protects you financially against a covered claim, even though you remain personally and legally identical to your business as a sole proprietor.
Why some sellers still consider getting both eventually
Many small business owners, once revenue grows to a meaningful level, decide to form an LLC and keep insurance, treating them as complementary rather than either/or:
- Insurance handles the financial side of a covered claim, up to your policy limits.
- An LLC can add a layer of personal asset protection for situations insurance doesn’t cover, or if a claim exceeds your policy limits.
Neither one makes the other unnecessary — sellers who form an LLC but skip insurance are still financially exposed for the cost of any claim, and sellers who buy insurance but stay a sole proprietor are covered up to their policy limits but don’t have the additional entity-level asset separation an LLC can provide.
Does forming an LLC change your insurance costs or requirements?
Generally, insurers price policies based on your product category, revenue, and coverage limits — not your business structure. Being an LLC versus a sole proprietor typically doesn’t significantly change your insurance quote, though it’s worth mentioning your business structure when getting a quote in case a specific provider handles this differently.
A practical way to think about the order
If you’re just starting out and trying to prioritize, it’s reasonable to:
- Get insurance first if your product category carries real injury risk (candles, cosmetics, children’s items) — this protects you financially from day one, regardless of business structure.
- Consider an LLC later, once you have a clearer sense of your revenue and risk level, ideally with input from an accountant or attorney about whether it makes sense for your specific situation and location.
There’s no rule requiring this order — it’s simply a reasonable way to avoid treating “I haven’t formed an LLC yet” as a reason to delay getting covered.
Frequently asked questions
Will an insurance provider ask if I have an LLC?
Some applications ask about your business structure as part of the quote process, but it’s typically for their records rather than a requirement to qualify for coverage as a sole proprietor.
Does an LLC protect me from a product liability claim even without insurance?
An LLC can help shield your personal assets from a business liability claim, but the business itself would still need to pay any judgment or settlement — without insurance, that money has to come from the business’s own funds, which for a small Etsy shop is often limited.
Is it more expensive to insure an LLC than a sole proprietorship?
Not typically — pricing is generally driven by product risk, revenue, and coverage limits rather than business structure itself, though it’s worth confirming with your specific provider.
Should I talk to an accountant before deciding on an LLC?
Yes, this is generally a good idea — LLC formation involves tax and legal considerations specific to your location and situation that go beyond what insurance alone addresses, and a professional can advise on whether it makes sense for your specific circumstances.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute insurance, legal, or financial advice. Insurance coverage, requirements, and costs vary by state, country, insurer, and individual business circumstances. Always confirm your specific coverage needs directly with a licensed insurance agent or broker before making a purchasing decision.

Leave a Reply